In the Network: Media Co-opDominion   Locals: HalifaxMontrealTorontoVancouver

Languages

Support the Media Co-op
Donate today!

Useful Information

Partenaires média/Media partners:

Advertisement
Join the Media Co-op

My blog

Blog entries by Tim McSorley

posted by Tim McSorley
Pandas, better take off your mask. The SPVM may be deem your costumes unreasonable. Via Anarchopanda on Facebook.

In the sweepstakes that pitted all three levels of government against each other to see who could pass the most draconian law first, the city of Montreal has come out on top.

Over the past week, it was announced that the Conservative party backs a law that would impose up to 10 years in jail for protesting with your face covered, the Quebec government introduced draconian legislation restricting the right to assembly and to protest, and the city of Montreal sped up the process to vote on two bylaws that are aimed at cracking down on protesters in Montreal.

The Montreal bylaws passed first, after councilors voted 33 for and 25 against. The first bylaws requires protest organizers to submit the details of any demonstration to the Montreal police beforehand, or else it will be immediately deemed an illegal assembly.

The second bylaw stipulates that no protesters are allowed to participate in demonstration with their face covered "without reasonable motives." Whether a protester has "reasonable motives" is left to police to decide on the spot. Found guilty of this infraction, and protesters will face up to $3,000 in fines (in the case of repeat offenders).

The new rules come into effect as of Saturday morning (once they are published in the newspapers).

Opposition politicians, including the vice-president of the public safety committee who originally backed the by-laws, have spoken out against the law. Other critics include the Quebec Bar Association and all but one person who spoke at a public consultation on Wednesday.

The exact wording of the by-laws:

2.1 Au préalable de sa tenue, le lieu exact et l'itinéraire, le cas échéant, d'une assemblée, d'un défilé ou autre attroupement doit être communiqué au directeur du Service de police ou à l'officier responsable.

3.2 Il est interdit à quiconque participe ou est...

posted by Tim McSorley
Over 500 artists speak out in support of Quebec student strike

As student associations vote one after the other to reject the most recent government offer, and as questions are increasing exponentially about how and when a solution to the current political crisis will come, the student movement received another wave of support today as 500 artists signed on to a public letter supporting the strike.

Including the likes of comic artist Julie Doucet, well known directors Sylvie Van Brabant, Hugo Latulippe and Paule Baillargeon, and certainly students and teachers of the arts, it's another indication that as the strike stretches through a 13th week, support continues.

The letter was published today on http://artistescontrelahausse.org. It reads in part:

The dramatic tuition increase being imposed by the Liberal government will further threaten equitable access to education and will bury future generations under massive debt. It represents a neoliberal policy of austerity economics that targets the social infrastructure of Québec and reinforces systemic social inequalities.

The assault on education is also an assault on culture. Artists and cultural workers also produce knowledge, they engage in the vitality of public discourse and ideas. The ideology underlying the current changes in the universities, of which the tuition hike is only one aspect, is the same ideology that aims to privatise and commodify our cultural production.

This isn't the first time artists have spoken out. Earlier in the spring, a short video was produced featuring 15 or so well known Quebec artists, during the Jutra awards for the best in Quebec cinema, several artists wore red squares on stage, and on May 1 another 153 artists also signed on to another open letter.

You can read the full letter below, or visit http://artistescontrelahause.org for more information.

Les artistes solidaires avec la grève générale des étudiants et étudiantes du Québec

Nous, soussigné-e-s, artistes, auteur-e-s, cinéastes, musiciens et musiciennes, travailleurs et travailleuses culturelles...
posted by Tim McSorley
Victoriaville: les balles de plastique sont identifiées

Ce billet à été écrit par le documentariste et membre de la Co-op média Moïse Marcoux-Chabot sur sa page Facebook mardi matin et fait depuis le tour des réseaux sociaux et d'internet. Vous pouvez lire l'original - et suivre le débat sur sa page. Notez que que l'article a atteint 3000 partages en moins de 30 heures et que depuis ce matin, Moïse n'a plus accès à son compte et ne peut plus y lire ses messages. On peut le joindre à l'adresse info@moisemarcouxchabot.com.

-Tim

 

En filmant les événements de vendredi dernier à Victoriaville, j'ai capté avec mon micro directionnel cette conversation entre deux agents anti-émeute, à l'arrière d'une ligne de policiers, pendant qu'un troisième s'approchait d'eux et qu'un quatrième, plus près, m'intimait «Bouge !». Il était 19h55, six minutes avant qu'un véhicule policier traverse dangereusement la foule.

 

Le premier interpelle les deux autres en pointant...

posted by Tim McSorley

 

Quickly translated from the great post by Simon Tremblay-Pépin of IRIS here.

So the Charest government has made a new proposal to end the crisis.

Costed-out proposals

First, the government proposes the tuition fee increase be spread out over 7 years, as opposed to 5. This increase includes indexation to the rate of inflation during the two extra years; the increase therefore goes from $1,625 to $1,779. Economist Gérald Fillion explains this well on his blog.

The government also proposes offering $39 million more in bursaries, available to households earning less than $45,000 per year. The government says this increase in bursaries will cost nothing to taxpayers, as it will be funded through the existing tuition fee tax credit. The tax credit costs the government $140 million; so it will be reduced by nearly 30 per cent.

There's no doubt that bursaries are more interesting than tax credits (bursaries are immediate, whereas tax credits come after expenses). At the same time, we cannot consider these bursaries as having a completely 'new' impact on accessibility to higher education. In fact, families that have decided, “I will pay for my child's studies because I'll have access to a tax credit,” will now find that argument less convincing. This reduces - although doesn't eliminate - the impact of these new bursaries.

Moreover, on April 5, the Minister of Education announced an increase in loans that would be financed through existing funding to universities – funding which the schools would need to compensate for by seeking out more donations. Therefore, with these new proposals (like the previous ones) the government puts no new money on the table, it proceeds only to make a few accounting operations - some of them slightly advantageous - by moving funds around.

Non-costed measures

Two elements that the government did not focus upon as much in its 'overall solution' (because they were already presented on April 5) are in reality important steps backward. This...

posted by Tim McSorley
Fifteen thousand take to Montreal streets as Quebec government plays semantics, blocks negotiations
Fifteen thousand take to Montreal streets as Quebec government plays semantics, blocks negotiations
Fifteen thousand take to Montreal streets as Quebec government plays semantics, blocks negotiations

It didn't take long; as always, the consensus among the media came quickly: Downtown turns into battlefield, Another demonstration goes sour, Montreal student demonstration turns violent, Violence breaks out during student protest... 

At the end of a day where 15,000 people took to the streets, a day that saw the provincial government play the worst kind of politics during negotiations with student representatives, you'd be hard pressed to get any of that from the night's headlines.

Also invisible from those opening lines are any mention of police actions. Actions which, if you were watching the live stream from CUTV, checking out clips on Youtube, or even following nearly any twitter feed (let alone if you were actually at the protest), did more to set off tensions than anything protesters did tonight.

The day's events were set in motion by Education Minister Line Beauchamp's announcement that she was expelling the Coalition Large de l'Association pour une Solidarité Syndicale Étudiante from the negotiating session meant to find a resolution to the 11-week-old student strike that has swept the province. CLASSE represents 50 per cent of the 180,000 students on strike and were largely responsible for launching the strike in the first place. They have also been a constant thorn in the side of the government, organizing the most radical acts of civil disobedience and maintaining a firm line of demanding the continuation of the province's tuition fee freeze.

Why were they expelled? After the coalition adopted a clear position against violence towards people, but encouraging civil disobedience, Minister Beauchamp demanded that CLASSE agree to a 48-hour truce...

posted by Tim McSorley
And crooked like La Presse poll results?

I support the student strike. I think other people should too. I'll argue with people who are in favour of tuition fee increases; I think it's a legitimate discussion though, and believe there are intelligent arguments in favor of the hike. I just don't agree with them.

I wanted to get that out of the way so there are no pretensions here. Each journalist has their opinion about the strike and fee increases, but we don't hear them because these opinions either a) are not supposed to exist or b) are not supposed to matter. I think there are ways to produce accurate and fair reporting even through your own bias; I try to do it myself.

But those biases are there, and we all have opinions. There is nothing more frustrating, though, than when opinions and biases are passed off as scientific fact.

And that appears to be what is splashed across pages two and three of La Presse today. While some La Presse columnists have been sympathetic to the strike, their editorial pages have not. This does not de facto deligitimize their coverage of the strike. But it does raise some serious questions.

Today's article states the the Quebec population are 60 per cent in favor of the tuition fee increase, while 60 per cent also believe the government should negotiate with students. Maybe those numbers are correct, and that would be disappointing, but that's fine. The issue, though, is that La Presse and polling agency CROP can't say whether or not the numbers are correct, and that is highly problematic.

In the fine print of the infographic they have showing the poll results, they state that:

Méthodologie: Le sondage a été mené en ligne auprès de 800 répondants les 28 et 29 mars derniers. Les résulats ont été pondérés afin de refléter la distribution de la population adulte du Québec selon le sexe, l'âge, la région et la langue maternelle des répondants. Compte tenu du chractère non probabiliste de l'échantillon, le calcul de la marge d'erreur ne s'applique pas. [emphasis mine]

This means that 800 people were surveyed online; the results were sorted to reflect the Quebec population, but it is a non-probabilistic sample. That's...

posted by Tim McSorley
Over 200,000 students on strike against tuition fee increases in Quebec

The student strike across Quebec is gaining momentum, with a growing number of daily actions and a record 215,000 students on strike.

As of today, according to the Coalition large de l'Association pour une solidarité sydicale étudiante (CLASSE), around 215 036 students from 163 associations are on strike. Over 175,000 of those students are also on unlimited strike, while the remainder are boycotting classes for a limited period, mostly around the March 22 day of action being held in Montreal. Organizers are estimating more than 100,000 students will be in the streets that day.

The strike has been ongoing since early February, when the first students voted to walk out of classes in protest against an increase of $325 per year, for the next five years. This equals a 75 per cent increase in tuition fees. The Quebec government has said the increase is necessary in order for students to pay their fair share of the cost of university education. In today's provincial budget, there were no changes to either tuition fees or to financial aid. Finance Minister Raymond Bachand told media outlets that for him the issue was closed.

But pointing to studies that show higher education attendance rates drop when tuition fees are raised (regardless of financial aid packages) and that higher percentage of lower income students attend post-secondary institutions in Quebec than any other province, students have said that the issue is not jst one of dollars and cents, but of the choices made by society.

Even on the dollars and cents field, though, students have offered up responses. This includes a new study that shows that by increasing the number of invomce tax brackets, the Quebec government could raise more through a progressive tax system, that at the same time lowers tax rates for 87 per cent of the population. The plan would also raise enough funds, they say, to maintain the freeze and help fund other social programs such as...

posted by Tim McSorley

This is an open letter written by Anna Kruzynski and Eric Shragge, professors at the School of Community and Public Affairs, Concordia University,

Tuesday March 13th, 2012.

Two weeks ago, the undergraduate students in our School voted to go on strike; last week, our graduate students joined the ranks. This week, all students, graduate and undergraduate alike, will be boycotting classes. As Concordia faculty, we fully support the strike. Here are the top ten reasons why.

1. Tuition is an obstacle to post-secondary education. Studies show that as tuition rises, significant segments of the population will make the rational choice to not pursue post-secondary education. More debt is simply untenable for families who are already struggling to make ends meet. Like high school was 50 years ago, university education has today become a prerequisite for most jobs. It is also during university studies that students become self-reflexive and critical thinkers. University education must be accessible to all, irrespective of income.

2. This strike is for all of us. Tuition is a user fee. Just like the health tax. User fees are part and parcel of the neoliberal trend towards privatisation of public services. Each person, rich or poor, is expected to pay a fixed rate in exchange for services, rather than paying according to their revenue through taxation on income. User fees are an attack on the universality of public programs and on the common good. Unlike the comments of Concordia’s Provost, we do not believe that free services are of lesser value. Should we go back to having tuition in high schools? Students are currently the proxy, but the underlying issue impacts everyone.

3. The government is ignoring mounting criticism. For over two years now, workers, organisations, students, ordinary folks, have been denouncing the Liberal government’s plans to institute austerity measures to stimulate the economy. All kinds of tactics have been used – letter-writing, petitions, memoirs, and symbolic street protests. This government has responded by ignoring, marginalising or repressing all those who dare question its priorities. The time has come to use stronger tactics.

4. All reforms are the result of conflict over interests. History shows that all the good that the...

posted by Tim McSorley
Huffington Post Quebec: The 'progressive' alternative?

Just a few weeks ago, the Huffington Post Quebec was born, an all-French language, Quebec-based version of the extremely-popular blog and news site founded by Arrianna Huffington. The HuffPo as styled itself as a populist, left-of-centre outlet in opposition to more conservative outlets like the Drudge Rport and Big News.

Fast forward to today: some 15,000 students took to the streets of Montreal as part of the province-wide, 62,000 student strong strike against tuition fee hikes. The protection of the right to accessible education through low tuition fees is one of the fundamental rallying points of the left and progressive activists across QUebec. With the Charest government lifiting the freeze in 2007 and announcing a furhter increase of 75 per cent over the next five years, the student movement has mobilized towards an unlimited general strike, with most of the left and centre left (and much of the centre) lending it's support.

How does Huffington Post Quebec cover it? Click the image in the top left corner to see a screen grab from 6pm today.

As a news outlet, the HuffPo surely doesn't need to line up unciritcally behind the student movement. But when its main hedline describing today's actions (a march and the blockage of traffic downtown) calls the situation "CHAOS," and that the main blog bost they are promoting on the topic is a weak attempt to deligitimize the movement by questioning whether it can be called a stirke (and not addressing the fundamental question at stake), one would wonder if they aren't simply lined up on the same side as Péladeau, Qubébecor and Sun News...

UPDATE: I didn't mean that last question to be as rhetorical as it may be, with Managing Editor Patrick White coming from Quebecor's Canoë.ca and the Journal de Québec, where from 2006 to 2009 he served as head of news at the paper (including during the messy year-long lock-out where the company was...

posted by Tim McSorley

OR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

Feb. 9, 2012, 2:30pm
 
Students outside throw oranges to sixth floor; FOUR caught by partiers at window
 
The partiers on the sixth floor of James Admin ecstatically announce that we have caught 4 oranges heroically launched from the ground below to the northeast-facing window we control. This is the first successful delivery of food from the outside. We extend infinite gratitude to our allies on the ground, and are working on further collaboration.
 
- 30 -
 

About the Media Co-op

The Media Co-op is a network of member-supported, local, democratic news organizations across Canada. The Media Co-op publishes the Dominion. Watch a video about the Media Co-op. Become a member of the Media Co-op. Read More.

User login

Advertisement